JA
warns of gold provision in Wall Street bill July 12, 2010
New York--Jewelers of America (JA) is warning retailers
about a piece of legislation designed to clamp down on trade
in "conflict" gold and minerals that the organization
predicts could be a "nightmare" for the jewelry
industry if enacted.
In an alert sent to National Jeweler and addressed to the
chief executive officers of firms using gold as well as
the minerals coltan, cassiterite and wolframite, JA warned
that the "Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer
Protection Act," legislation that is designed to bring
sweeping changes to Wall Street, includes a section that
would have a big impact on the jewelry industry. The addendum
to the bill is meant to ensure minerals aren't subsidizing
conflicts in the Democratic Republic of Congo, as well as
nine surrounding countries: Angola, Zambia, Tanzania, Burundi,
Rwanda, Uganda, Sudan, the Central African Republic and
Congo.
According to JA, the provision, section 1502, dictates
that companies using gold or any of the other minerals mentioned
above will have to file annual reports with the Securities
and Exchange Commission (SEC) regarding the source of those
materials, a step that the organization believes will surely
require companies to hire a third-party firm to audit and
validate the reports.
"We cannot imagine making a disclosure to the SEC
if you didn't do an audit to know for a fact it would stand
up," said JA Chief Operating Officer Robert Headley.
If a company's gold or minerals did originate from one
of the 10 African countries included in the bill, then that
company would have to show what steps they took to trace
their materials back to their source.
Headley said that while JA is against materials of any
kind that support conflict, it views the bill--which would
impact a large number of industry players, including retailers--as
"impractical" as written now given the current
lack of traceability in the supply chain.
"How would anyone know [where their gold is coming
from] unless you're buying it from a particular mine only?"
he says. "Bottom line, it's too hard to trace."
In addition, the provision dictates that the materials
information be placed on the company's Web site for public
review; there is no allowance in the bill for those companies
that may not have Web sites.
The Dodd-Frank bill already has passed the U.S. House of
Representatives and is now being readied for a final vote
in the Senate. Senators, who have been on a break, are slated
to return to their offices on Tuesday.
Headley said that the provision that could potentially
impact the jewelry industry, Section 1502, was "quite
recently" introduced and is a random add-on to the
bill, which is a piece of financial regulatory reform legislation.
"I think we would all acknowledge this has nothing
to do with this bill," he says.
In the alert, JA recommends members of the jewelry industry
contact their U.S. senators to ask them to defeat this provision
of the bill (Section 1502) or the entire bill if the provision
cannot be defeated. Contact information for each senator
can be obtained here.
To download a PDF of the Dodd Frank Wall Street Reform
and Consumer Protection Act, click
here.
To download a PDF of the portion of the bill containing
Section 1502 that could impact the jewelry industry, click
here.